Daria Wrubel Responses — select a question to learn more
I am in favor of the seven story limitation.
I am not in favor of lowering the on-site affordable housing requirements.
Yes, I could support revisiting the community-generated recommendations.
It is the responsibility of the city to take the input from those constituents most effected with seriousness and respect. When the Council chooses not to follow a community recommendation, it should publicly explain why.
There is a big difference between zoned capacity and actual construction for population. Changing zoning doesn't automatically double population. And yes, I do believe that rezoning commercial streets, especially along transit corridors, is necessary to meet both our housing and our climate goals. If we build more housing where people live and work, we can reduce our reliance on fossil fuels, which is essential to combatting climate change.
I believe each commercial corridor requires a capacity analysis - there is no one size fits all solution. Street width, setbacks, sunlight, surrounding trees, sidewalks, public spaces, building articulation, and ground-floor uses can matter as much as the raw story count. That being said, in my initial analysis of the San Pablo plan, four to five stories (before the state density bonus) makes sense to me.
I do not believe that the market can solve our housing crisis on its own. We must create policies that protect our most vulnerable residents. We must require deeply affordable units in market-rate developments. We must continue to use our Housing Trust Fund to finance 100% affordable development. We need to aggressively pursue state and federal subsidies, tax credits and nonprofit financing to use toward affordable housing projects like our Small Sites Program, and work with our state and federal partners to expand those opportunities.
We can do even more to encourage land trusts, nonprofits and the Small Sites Program to purchase existing rental buildings and permanently remove them from the speculative market. That can preserve lower-cost housing without waiting years for new construction.
We can do more to get large institutional investors out of the housing market. Housing is a human right, and there should be no room for corporate landlords in Berkeley.
I would much prefer if every housing development included on-site affordable units, but I also recognize that in-lieu fees (what you are describing here) are the main source of funding for our Housing Trust Fund, and the city has done wonderful things with those funds. I want to make sure that in-lieu fees are reviewed regularly so that they are set at the highest rate that still encourages housing development, while maximizing the benefit to our Housing Trust Fund.
The state of California has suppressed the construction of new housing for decades, and Berkeley in particular has set exclusionary zoning laws that have not only suppressed housing development, but advanced unjust and racist conditions. I believe the middle housing ordinance is a major step towards correcting these failed policies.
However, we should revisit the policy regularly to see if it is having its intended effect, and to make course corrections in the case of negative unintended consequences.
I support the designation of historic landmarks, but not historic districts. It is deeply important to support preservation of significant sites -- landmarks with real architectural, cultural, Indigenous, civil-rights, labor, or artistic significance.
I appreciate that the Hopkins Street bike lanes have become a very contentious issue, and a stand-in for many existing tensions between different groups in Berkeley. My understanding is that the city has already studied the needs and alternatives to Class IV cycle tracks, and that is why the council voted 7-2 to advance that plan. I wish the city had done a better job of communicating the results of those studies, and done more to address the concerns of opponents. The city has an obligation to educate the public about decisions like this.
However, given the fact that the city approved this plan, the role of a new councilmember is to make sure the final engineering plan keeps the promises included in the referral approved on July 28th. As an elected official, I would be looking for the following imperatives: First, is ADA access increased? Currently the only ADA parking is within the Monterey Market parking lot. Has parking been preserved along one side of the street between California and The Alameda, for access to businesses and recreation sites? Thirdly, will the request from local businesses for extra loading zone space be honored? In other words, is the plan being put forward a good faith effort to meet the needs of the community? Only then would I approve the final plan.
Hopkins is slated for repaving in the 2027-2028 fiscal year, and I fully support working to prevent any further delays. The most efficient path to repaving would be to include all the pedestrian, ADA, bike safety, transit access, and traffic-calming improvements at one time. I think that goal is achievable.
I believe a livable city should meet the needs of human beings, not corporations.
I believe in human scale where buildings, streets, sidewalks, and public spaces are designed around people's experience at ground level. Human scale does not necessarily mean low-rise. Height is one factor, alongside street width, setbacks, sunlight, and trees.
Human scale also includes community and social connection. A livable city provides places where relationships can form -- at cafés, parks, libraries, neighborhood businesses, schools, plazas, community centers, theaters, farmers' markets, music venues, etc.
A livable city is also a city with housing people can afford.
That includes market-rate housing but also permanently affordable housing for people whose incomes cannot afford market rents, as well as housing for families, seniors, people with disabilities, and people living alone.
And this is an issue that gets talked about less and less, a livable city is also an environmentally conscious city. Trees, parks, biodiversity, clean air, reduced greenhouse-gas emissions, access to nature, energy-efficient buildings, protection from excessive heat, and responsible use of land and water all contribute to livability.
A city for the entire lifespan, for our children to our seniors, with a bustling local economic life, democratic participation, and continuity.
I made a video on aspects of a livable city here: